Customer Reviews - Steak Loft of Mystic CT

Well known steak house with a very good bar. I got the steak tips and a double of Knob Creek my wife got the seafood medley and a diet coke and Captain Morgan spiced rum as we're doing the Keto diet right now. Fast and friendly service from the waite staff.

Allen Knapp

14:44 05 Nov 22

quiet little steak house on the edge of old Mystic village. One of my favorite places to eat in the area. price to portion size is spot on, quality of service and food is amazing. all around awesome place to go for a special night out.

Karen McGrath Scarcello

21:49 11 Oct 22

We just celebrated my birthday there with 12 people. It was very nice, good service.

Julian Young

00:23 19 Sep 22

Good food

Sylvia Foster

19:17 12 Sep 22

Wonderful lunch. Great punctual service

Aaron Lewis

12:43 23 Aug 22

PLEASE READ THE ENTIRE REVIEWI can totally understand the mixed reviews and if we had only eaten here the second visit, I would never return.We were in Mystic for 2 days, we ate dinner here on Sunday evening and everything, I mean everything was fantastic.The steak, the sides, the desert, the salads, namely the Grain Salad could not have been better and the service was excellent.So good in fact we went back on Monday for lunch, just for the Grain Salad. Yes it was that good!However, round two was somewhat of a Murphy's law visit. Just about everything was wrong. Firstly, the girl at the door was more than rude.The same salad that delivered amazing presentation and taste the evening before was now some kind of uneventful, thrown together bunch of greens missing half the ingredients.The cheesecake was, well, let's just say it didn't get eaten.However I want to note that we took home a carrot cake that was excellent. The flour-less chocolate tort is also amazing.We eventually spoke to the manager who was very polite and understanding. Apparently there was nothing 'wrong' with the cheesecake, it was just the taste of that vendors recipe that they would no longer be using.The issue with the salad was apparently a new untrained chef whereas the person who made it the night before had to be moved to line cook due to staffing shortages.So the end result is, this place has some damn good food. Very reasonably priced. Great portions and wonderful service.As long as the right people are working when you go.If you have a bad experience, tell them but give them a second chance.Well worth the visit, will definitely eat here again on our next trip.

Meth 18GT

15:39 05 Aug 22

Always great food and service.

Marc Medico

19:15 29 Jun 22

Excellent service, food atmosphere. Conveniently located near I 95 exit .

Jayy Abdullah

02:20 29 Jun 22

Fish and Chips 🥰🥰🥰

Colonial Tinker

23:02 27 Jun 22

I will say, the restaurant is a little on the darker side, but that is not a deterrent. Service was good. Got a soda and had many refills. The fish and chips were good, but I have had better and have had worse. What I enjoyed the most was the clam chowder and Caesar salad. The chowder had alot of flavor with no fishy taste at all. The salad was good, and had the right amount of dressing.

Julia DeLayo

10:24 27 Jun 22

Cannot say enough about the service. We celebrated a birthday and our server, Aki, was fantastic, he even made sure the birthday candles on the dessert were a surprise!The food was delicious and reasonably priced.

Vin Ortez

01:43 23 Jun 22

I love the Steak teriyaki with load baked potato. I miss the salad bar, good service.

Allen Zatonsky

18:38 17 Jun 22

Excellent food and service!

Jan Paul Kaim

11:49 14 Jun 22

Step back in time for a restaurant experience that keeps the spirit of yesteryear alive. Featuring well executed traditional American fare that you won't find at the trend-chasing (often corporate) restaurants or the modern era, the Steak Loft is a comfortable, calm and enjoyable place to share a meal with loved ones. The stuffed shrimp were wonderful and made my grandmother so happy to see them on a menu (she's been looking for a place that still serves them for years!). The service was kind, the food delicious and the overall experience wonderful. Is it a swanky new place redefining your favorite cuisine? Not at all! But if you lean in to the old-world charm, character and coziness of a bygone era, you may find this place to be as terrific as we did.

Jason T

20:41 10 Jun 22

Our favorite must visit restaurant whenever we come to Mystic. Cozy atmosphere. As of June 2022, the salad bar is no longer available as we were told it never came back from covid, but they give you any salad choice with your entree. And the salad servings are decent size. We first visited on a hunch for a Valentine's day meal about 5 years ago and was impressed enough to return multiple times. In fact, on one of our latest visits we ate here two nights in a row. Interesting simulated rustic decor in some areas of the restaurant while other areas could use an update. Stonington baked scallops (about $37) were very good as is the teriyaki flank steak which the server told us they marinate overnight to lock in the flavor. There is a full service bar with quick bites menu available and there is often live entertainment.We do miss the salad bar though and all the offerings that came with it. We were told it likely won't return this summer, as there are still staffing shortages, like every other business..For three adults and one child, 2 qb plates (appetizers), 3 entrees, no alcoholic beverages or deserts was about $200, including tip.The portions are deceiving. They look small but fill you up quickly.Look forward to visiting again.

Brat

12:01 29 May 22

Great experience in mystic village. Food great. Roghly 100 for 4 people for very full dinner. Help was very friendly and welcoming

Kati Häggström

00:58 28 May 22

Can’t understand how you can give less than five stars. On May 27, 2022 at 7.30 pm the crowd was great, waitress friendly and steaks perfect. Live music with a band of drummer, base, 2 guitars and a mandolin. America at it’s best.

nicole cardoza

16:01 25 May 22

Yum! Moist steak. Cooked exactly the way I requested. Drinks were made stronger here than probably anywhere else I have ever been. Totally worth the price. We went with quite the rowdy bunch and our waitress couldn't of been nicer or more patient. Can't wait to try my next meal 😋

James Bucci

20:39 19 May 22

Service good food good drink good altogether my wife and I had a great time

Dylan H

17:12 16 May 22

Service and staff were great. I though food was priced pretty well for the steaks and the food tasted good. However, this place need a renovation. The restaurant use to be an actual barn. The dimly lit rooms, dirty bathrooms, falling apart wallpaper and other decor were all a little unsettling.

Klaus Stankiewicz

21:47 15 May 22

Nice fish & chips with a choice of salad. I give it only 4 stars as the salad bar was closed for COVID. Not their fault, I had my mind for salad bar, their's is normally great. Great staff too.

Rachel G

09:42 15 May 22

So cozy comfortable and great food

Heidi Hansen Boone

18:20 30 Apr 22

Best server Bonnie was beyondgreat and helpful food was amazing. It was my first time there but won't be my last!!!!

David Abbot

02:45 28 Apr 22

Great Ribeye!

E K

23:16 21 Apr 22

Good service! The food was excellent!